A Galveston defense attorney was escorted from the 56th District Court Friday after a dispute with Judge Lonnie Cox that quickly escalated in a case of a man who shot himself in fear of a prison sentence.

Attorney Mark Metzger in a motion to dismiss a case against Luke Thomas Pavilonis, accused Cox of capriciousness in rejecting a plea agreement that later led the defendant to shoot and kill himself, Metzger said.

“I’m really not going to take the blame for a man who kills himself,” Cox said. “I’m not going to take the blame for attorneys not being prepared and present and explaining what the case was about. I will not blindly take pleas.”

Metzger, on behalf of Pavilonis, had reached a tentative plea agreement with the Galveston County District Attorney’s Office several weeks ago in which Pavilonis would plead guilty to one count of intoxication assault and would receive a sentence of 10 years probation, Chief Assistant District Attorney Rebecca Russell said.

Russell declined to comment about other matters of the case.

Pavilonis was accused of running a stop sign in March 2017 after drinking too much and slamming into the back of Mandi Yarbrough’s Mercury Cougar, causing a large laceration to her right shoulder, according to a probable cause affidavit.

When both sides showed up to the 56th District Court to present the plea agreement, Cox denied it.

“On the day the case was set for a plea, the prosecutor did not show up to the case,” Cox said. “They sent a substitute prosecutor who didn’t know anything about the case. When I asked the prosecutor whether the family was contacted and things like that, he didn’t know. So I wouldn’t take the plea. I’m not going to take a plea where the victim and family of the victim was not contacted.”

Cox didn’t sentence Pavilonis, but reset the plea date. But Pavilonis feared he would be facing prison time, Metzger said.

But Metzger accuses Cox of using his position as a judge to bully defendants.

“Circumstances did not warrant a rejection of this plea agreement and this capricious, uninformed and ill-advised decision did then deprive the defendant of a fair and reasonable disposition that comported with the interests of justice,” Metzger said in his motion to dismiss.

After the failed plea agreement, Pavilonis shot himself in the head and died June 19, Metzger said.

“I just asked him to sign the motion,” Metzger said, after he was escorted out by a bailiff Friday. “I wanted it as a memorial for his death — so that people know he wasn’t a coward, but a victim.”

Metzger said that Cox isn’t capable of fairly handling cases because he routinely refuses to accept probation sentences for defendants accused in DWI-related offenses.

“That’s often true, but his client wasn’t charged with a felony DWI,” Cox said. “His client was charged with intoxication assault.”

Metzger and Russell approached the bench Friday to discuss a possible dismissal, but the exchanged ended with Cox asking for a bailiff to escort Metzger out of the courtroom.

“Bailiff, take this man out of here,” Cox said.

Metzger cursed audibly on his way out of the courtroom.

Metzger said the fight wasn’t over.

“The family said they feel Luke was bullied by the court,” Metzger said. “I just asked him to sign the dismissal. He said he’d get around to it when he gets around to it.”

Cox said Friday was a particularly busy day on the docket, but that he would soon dismiss the case.

Matt deGrood: 409-683-5230; matt.degrood@galvnews.com



(9) comments

Bill Lowe

WOW GDNs!! This a very misleading headline. If you just read that it would believe Judge Cox had done something wrong. After reading the story I agree with Judge Cox. The more I read from the GDNs the less I believe it should be called a news paper. It should sit next to the Enquirer at the grocery store.

Good Job Judge Cox!!!

Harry Gendel

Mr. DeGrood's reporting was excellent. Sides were not taken. Headline was a grabber and the article stirred up the pot (see below).

David Doe

This country has gone to eggs in a hand basket. Maybe this so-called atty should receive a Participation trophy. What a Pathetic Excuse to use, especially when you are defending a CRIMINAL! Our society has turned into a bunch of crybabies!

George Croix

This is a perfect example of the abject insanity taking hold of way too many people.
As presented in this article, the Judge would have beeb derelict, imo, in accepting without verification or notification, and cannot be expected to be a mind reader.
If the accused killed himself, that's a shame, but he kill HIMSELF...

Tiffany Hendrix

What if this gentleman was your son, or brother? Kudos to the attorney for fighting for his clients family... All he wanted was for him to sign the dismissal and this rude judge had zero sympathy for the family! RIP

Nick Garza

He was blaming the judge for the guy committing suicide not just trying to get a dismissal. How about sympathy for the real victim?! The person who was injured while this guy decided to drive after drinking? If you can't do the time, don't do the crime!

Carol Dean

The only person responsible for committing suicide is the individual themselves.

Lisa Lohmann

How many crimes are committed by people on probation or bond. Not accepting a plea because the victim hasn't been notified is entirely reasonable. Good for Judge Cox being tough and advocating for victims.

Carol Dean


Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.

Thank you for Reading!

Please log in, or sign up for a new account and purchase a subscription to read or post comments.