Calling themselves victims of an activist judge, Galveston County Commissioners voted Monday to continue a five-year legal fight against a county probate court judge.

Commissioners voted 3-2 to appeal an October 2018 ruling ordering the county to pay more than $60,000 to attorneys representing probate court Judge Kimberly Sullivan.

The county was appealing because it had been wronged by the visiting judge’s ruling — and that the ruling set a dangerous precedent, County Judge Mark Henry said.

“Any judge now can set themselves any salary they want because of this ruling,” Henry said.

Visiting Judge Alice Oliver-Parrott ruled the county was wrong to remove a $5,000 budget line item that Sullivan had submitted to commissioners in 2014. The money was supposed to pay Sullivan for her services as the county’s local administrative statutory probate court judge.

Commissioners removed the budget line after questioning whether Sullivan, the county’s only probate court judge, needed to be paid for her work administering the court.

Sullivan sued in October 2014 arguing commissioners didn’t have the power to control the source of the funding. The $5,000 was not budgeted to be paid out of the county’s general fund, but from fees charged within the probate court, Sullivan said.

Oliver-Parrott called the county’s refusal to pay “arbitrary and capricious.”

The county had no choice but to appeal what amounted to the “new state law” Oliver-Parrott had handed down, Henry said.

Commissioners Darrell Apffel and Joe Giusti voted against the appeal.

Apffel objected to Henry’s characterization of the law regarding the issue. As it is written currently, the law allows administrative judges to give themselves a “reasonable” payment.

There’s no definition in the state law that says what reasonable is, Henry said. The county plans to advocate for a bill to be filed in the Texas Legislature to add that definition, he said.

The request for the appeal goes to the Texas Fourteenth Court of Appeals, to which the county had already made some preliminary filings in advance of Monday’s vote. No hearing dates had been set for the appeal as of Monday afternoon, according to court records.

The county could not say on Monday how much it has spent litigating the lawsuit with Sullivan.

John Wayne Ferguson: 409-683-5226; or on Twitter @johnwferguson.


(7) comments


So...Just the fact that Henry won’t say how MUCH OF YOUR TAXPAYERS MONEY he has spent on this BS...You know it’s more than the $60,000 they owe her!! This money is not his to govern. Stay in your lane, Henry! You don’t control everything!!!

Vanessa McAfee

It would be interesting to know how much we are paying defend elected officials for suits that could have been avoided. Here is a list of those named in suits we are paying to defend:
Galveston County District Court Judges
Kerry Neves,
Lonnie Cox,
John Ellisor,
Patricia Grady,
Anne Darring
Michelle Slaughter;
Galveston County Court at Law Judges
John Grady,
Barbara Roberts
Jack Ewing;
Galveston County Magistrates
Mark Baker,
Kerri Foley
James Woltz;
District Attorney Jack Roady,
Voter Registrar, Tax Assessor Cheryl Johnson
Kim Sullivan, Probate Judge

Paul Hyatt

What is even more interesting is that the people who allowed 500K to be stolen from them still have jobs?

Rusty Schroeder

What's even more interesting or shameful, is the disregard of the stolen money as business as usual in Galveston County. The "can't touch me' attitude of those involved is disgusting, the judges that govern the accused and the commissioners court should be embarrassed in their lack of concern over taxpayer money.

George Croix

Anyone can sue a ham sandwich, just because they want to....
Not everyone can screw away a half million bucks and skate away from it.

Jarvis Buckley

My thoughts are this reeks of dark politics. Ms. Sullivan doesn't seem to have done anything illegal or immoral. My guess is constituents
Gonna make a wholesale change .Come Election Day . Just my thoughts.......

Carol Dean

What do Henry, Clark and Holmes really care about this??? It won't be their money they will spend; once again it will be ours, the Tax-payers!

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.

Thank you for Reading!

Please log in, or sign up for a new account and purchase a subscription to read or post comments.