Marisol Martinez camped out on a chilly November evening on her 8-year-old son’s first overnight Cub Scout adventure.

This month is busier than usual for Martinez, who was camping with her Cub Scout, keeping up with her other two active children and cooking for her extended family’s large, traditional Thanksgiving dinner. She’s mashing potatoes and preparing a green noodle dish with poblano peppers. Her sister is making at least three casseroles. Her dad will cook the turkey outside on the grill. It’s his thing.

Martinez, who was born in Mexico, became a U.S. citizen in 2014. She had three good reasons: her children. Now, if she travels outside the United States, she doesn’t worry about some glitch in the system that might keep her away from home.

“You start thinking about your kids more than you,” Martinez, who lives in Galveston, said. “When you have to think about your kids, it’s important to make good choices.”

She’s living an American dream, contributing to the community and raising young Americans. But other immigrants don’t have the same resources and can’t offer the same opportunities to their children.

These are challenging and uncertain times for immigrants who don’t have citizenship, lawyers and activists said. A March 5 2018 deadline looms for some of the 113,000 young people living in Texas who were covered under the now rescinded Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program and who are not sure what comes next.

More than 33,000 immigrants sought advice on that and other concerns in 2016 from Houston-based St. Frances Cabrini Center for Immigrant Legal Assistance, part of the Catholic Charities of the Archdiocese of Galveston-Houston. Some of those immigrants worry about government agencies having their information, program director and lawyer Zenobia Lai said.

About 2,000 young people in Galveston County are in limbo after President Donald Trump in September rescinded the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, and they could be deported although they grew up in the United States, Lai said.

One in six Texas residents is an immigrant, and 15 percent of Texas residents are native-born U.S. citizens with at least one immigrant parent, according to a November American Immigration Council study.

In Texas, 2.36 million of the state’s 7 million children live in immigrant families, and 80 percent of them live in two-parent homes, an October Annie E. Casey Foundation report said.

The foundation wants state and federal policies that keep families together, help children in immigrant families thrive and create well-paying jobs for their parents.

While the Martinez family is thriving, many immigrant families stumble with a lack of opportunities, according to the foundation report.

And some don’t have the family connections or resources to get the proper and sometimes expensive paperwork to become legal residents or U.S. Citizens.


St. Frances Cabrini Center for Immigrant Legal Assistance helped about 10,000 people in the Greater Houston area in 2016, Lai said.

“An additional 23,559 received information or legal consultation through our ‘charlas,’ outreach, presentation and workshops,” Lai said.

Charla means chat in Spanish, and the center holds three of them every month to explain immigration rights and to give individual legal consultation, Lai said.

Many immigrants in Galveston don’t always get a lawyer because of the money and they assume that they have to travel to Houston, grass roots groups said.


Ser y Hacer, a Galveston-based grass roots organization, tries to fill a void. It offers free English classes and citizenship classes to immigrants in Galveston, and it also helps with filling out paperwork to apply for residency, citizenship and other legal paperwork.

Ser y Hacer in Spanish means to be and to do, or being and doing. Magdalena Alvarado started Ser y Hacer in 2012 just one year after she became a U.S. citizen. She was well aware of the hurdles, she said.

“There’s a necessity here in Galveston,” Alvarado said. “Everyone says ‘I need to go to Houston.’”

Alvarado had to go to Houston to see lawyers, get general advice and attend a citizenship class to prepare for the 100-question exam.

To come up with an island-based solution, Alvarado networked with Galveston Independent School District officials and city leaders.

She also worked with the U.S. Customs and Immigration Service to set up classes to help immigrants become citizens.

“They are a liaison that works for us,” she said. “It is a huge collaboration.”

She met Mary Longoria at city hall when she first started the organization, and soon Longoria became her partner at Ser y Hacer.

Alvarado and Longoria work as unpaid volunteers who post fliers about classes, counsel immigrants and help them find scholarships and jobs.

“We love to do that,” Longoria said. “We love the people, the community, the families. To know the people is the best part.”


Yadira Araujo, who is from the Monterrey area in Mexico, has gone to Ser y Hacer to get help filing paperwork for her family. It costs $750 to file some forms.

“And the lawyers charge that, too,” Araujo said. At Ser y Hacer, she just has to pay whatever the filing fees are and she doesn’t have to double the cost with lawyer fees.

“They’ve helped me with my children,” Araujo said.

She has a 15-year-old daughter who was born on the island. She also has a 17-year-old son who she brought to Galveston when he was 6 months old.

Araujo and her husband came to Galveston in 2000 on a travel and business visa, but they didn’t go back to Mexico, she said. It’s a complicated situation. While her daughter is a U.S. citizen, her son is not.

He’s in that group of young people commonly referred to as “Dreamers,” a term based on never-passed proposals in Congress called the DREAM Act that would have provided protections for young immigrants. The DREAM Act — Development, Relief and Education for Alien Minors — was a federal proposal that offered protections for immigrants brought to the United States as young children.

But it didn’t become a law.


While Congress never passed the DREAM Act, another program sought to offer similar protections. That was the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program that former President Barack Obama’s administration implemented. The administrative program allowed young immigrants living in the country illegally who were brought here as children to remain in the United States. It did not convey legal status.

DACA granted nearly 800,000 young people two-year work permits and temporary protection from deportation and permission to legally work.

Of those 800,000, about 113,000 were in Texas. About 2 percent to 3 percent of the 113,000 are in Galveston County, Lai said. That would mean about 2,000 to 3,000 young people.

President Donald J. Trump’s administration announced Sept. 5 that it would end the program in March 2018. The Trump administration gave recipients 30 days to submit renewal applications if their permits would expire before the program ends.


Cesar Araujo, 17, is a senior at Ball High School who wants to study economics at Texas A&M University, possibly starting at the Galveston branch then transferring to the College Station campus. He did well in his advanced placement economics class.

“I like dealing with money,” he said. “I like how orderly it is.”

He has a girlfriend. They went out to see “Jigsaw” at a movie theater recently. He likes to play single-shooter video games such as “Counter-Strike: Global Offensive.” He works part-time at Marshalls on Stewart Road in Galveston, where it can get busy with tourists on Sunday afternoons, he said.

He watches documentaries on history and science, which he thinks makes him seem weird to his friends, he said.

Cesar Araujo was that 6-month-old baby that came to Galveston and never left. He met the October deadline to renew his DACA application. It was approved, and he can stay in the country through 2019.

Something else about Cesar Araujo — he likes President Trump.

“It’s not what you expect,” he said, and grinned like a senior in high school.

He’s not worried about what happens to him after 2019 and is optimistic about his future.

“I also try to be a realist,” he said. “For me, I’ll accept reality. I love this country and even the laws that come with it.”

But if he should be deported to Mexico, he’ll be at a disadvantage. He doesn’t speak Spanish well, he said. And his mom agrees with that. He’s also not familiar with Mexican culture. All he knows is Galveston.

Cesar Araujo has gotten into heated debates about immigration policy at school with classmates yelling at him that he doesn’t know what he’s talking about, he said. He usually tells them that, yes, he knows quite a bit about immigration policy. And he notices all the misconceptions people who are not in his situation have from the idea that undocumented immigrants are all Mexicans to the notion that all immigrants are stupid or criminal.

And even though he could be deported in a couple of years if Congress doesn’t create legislation to fix the issue, he’s not certain that DACA was ever fair to other immigrants who couldn’t use the program.

“I’m just an honest man,” he said. “I look at things from both sides.”


“Most people agree our immigration system is broken,” Lai said. “We are tearing apart families.”

She points to a Migration Policy Institute study comparing the jobs that DACA recipients held to their cohorts. DACA recipients tend to work in office settings and hold professional jobs.

“We are talking about a significant number of important, contributing members of the economy,” Lai said. “However tenuous their connection is with our country, we need to do what can we do to help the ‘Dreamers.’ They grew up as our neighbors, they grew up as our friends and now they are our co-workers.”

The U.S. immigration system is dysfunctional and needs an overhaul, she said. Only a small number can get education waivers. Immigrants seeking a humanitarian status have to file within the first year they are here.

“It’s not a good time for immigrants,” Lai said.


Martinez’s immigration story starts with her grandfather who gained U.S. resident status in the 1970s. He worked in Galveston and extended the resident status to her father.

Her mother, who got homesick, went back to Mexico where Martinez was born and where she grew up. Martinez got a degree in computer science while she lived in Mexico, but she couldn’t find any jobs.

So she went to her other home, Galveston.

A few years later, she met her future husband, who is from El Salvador, when a mutual relative had a baby. He had moved to Galveston with his parents when he was 10 years old.

“I really admire my in-laws,” Martinez said. “My mother-in-law started selling jewelry from a catalog when she came here.”

Now, her in-laws own and operate Martinez Furniture Center on Broadway in Galveston. They opened the store in 1997.

“They never gave up,” she said.

Martinez encourages other immigrants to work hard like her in-laws and motivate their children to get an education. She also recommends taking the path to citizenship.

“Make it happen,” she said. “You can have dreams, but it’s better to make it happen.”

Valerie Wells: 409-683-5246;


(7) comments

PD Hyatt

If people would not come across the border illegally and actually thought about their children before becoming a criminal then the children would not be in this position.... If we are going to say that no crimes were broken then why do we have any laws on the books if we are not going to enforce them.... The media can make a sob story out of anything and what they are real good about is NOT telling the whole truth and the whole story.... Of course that is what I have come to expect from any of the local media as they seem to have a real problem reporting the truth but have no problem reporting half truths or what they used to call out right lies....

timothy spencer

" “Dreamers,” a term based on never-passed proposals in Congress called the DREAM Act that would have provided protections for young immigrants. The DREAM Act — Development, Relief and Education for Alien Minors — was a federal proposal that offered protections for immigrants brought to the United States as young children.

But it didn’t become a law."
This article contains a lot of words but did I overlook "illegal aliens"? As you wrote it never became a law and the laws in ths country dealing with these matters needs to be strictly enforced, period. Not enforcing the law is the fault of our politicians but now is the time to get back to doing things according to the law.

Randy Chapman

Many if not most reporting on the immigration issue leaves out the fact that all this started with ILLEGAL CRIMINAL ALIENS. It's simple really; respect our laws and do things the right way. Sorry that some kids' parents were idiots and thought they could do as they wanted, and now the kids may have to go live with the parents in the native country, but laws are laws, and they are needed.

Christopher Smith

Great story! Thank you Valerie and Daily News for reporting this complicated story. I love that these families are working so hard to chase their American dreams. They are truly productive members of society, giving back so much to the community and to their families. I hope our immigration laws get fixed so that folks like these can live and work here without the fear of being deported.

Jose' Boix

The featured Martinez family; just like I was blessed and fortunate to have, was a seemingly defined path to Citizenship. The travesty, in my opinion is that: There is no confirmed path to Citizenship (often twisted as Amnesty), and there is no effective enforcement mechanism. We keep adding patches and acts, and we can't even enforce these newly created approaches. And at the end, there seems to be a consensus that it would be impractical - and probably impossible to do - to deport all illegals/undocumented. So we continue to reach an impasse. Just my thoughts.

Gary Miller

Most of them grew up as Americans. Unfortunately 107,000 of them have criminal records. About the same as American youth records. If they learned english, have jobs, pay their taxes, have no criminal record and want citizenship they have earned it. One string should be included, no voting for one election cycle or 6 years.

Jose' Boix

Mr. Miller, from my experience I immigrated into this great Country, November 1960 with a Visa, entered the refugee program within days and eventually was able to become a Citizen November 11, 1969. Only then I was able to exercise my right and privilege to vote.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.

Thank you for Reading!

Please log in, or sign up for a new account and purchase a subscription to read or post comments.